Germs in Your Gut Are Talking to Your Brain/Gut bacteria linked to mental well-being and depression4/2/2019 by Kaitlyn MayThe New York Times article, “Germs in Your Gut are Talking to Your Brain,” discusses a newer wave of research exploring the relationship between the microbiome system and the brain. More and more, research in this area is increasing and pointing a critical role of microbiome in neural disorders such as autism, Alzheimer’s, Parkinson’s, depression, and others. The hypothesis is that there are a few species of microbes in the gastrointestinal system that play a key role in the development of neural disease and disorders via the release of chemicals that alter how immune cells work in the brain.
This area of research has been overlooked for years, largely because of the difficulties of studying these species in a lab; the majority of the microbes of the human system cannot survive in a petri dish. A key finding—the discovery of a way to sequence DNA from these microbes—served as a catalyst to the development of this area of research. Even then, little thought was given to the influence of the microbiome on the brain. Prior research indicated that the blood-brain barrier acted as a “sift” for the brain, only allowing small molecules to pass through. The New York Times article goes through seminal studies in this line of research. Each study relates various aspects of the microbiome to a different neurological disorder, such as Alzheimer’s, depression, autism, or seizures. The majority of these studies examine individual strains of bacteria in mouse models. For example, Dr. Costa-Mattioli at Baylor College of Medicine used mouse models of autism to examine how differences in the microbiome affected autism symptomatology. Dr. Costa-Mattioli found that the animals lacked Lactobacillus and adding this strain of bacteria to their diet reduced repetitive and anti-social behaviors. He researches revealed that the bacteria communicated to nerve endings in the intestines, and that these signals would be sent from gut to brain, where they would affect the production of the oxytocin hormone that promotes social bonds. Similarly, examination of the role of the microbiome in epileptic mice on a ketogenic diet identified a key role of the microbiome. A ketogenic diet has long been a key treatment for individuals with epilepsy, as the diet reduces seizures. When this diet was fed to epileptic mice raised free of microbes, these mice did not see a reduction in seizures. However, if they received stool from mice who were on a ketogenic diet, there seizures were reduced. This was because it is the microbiome which communicates to the brain. The research identified two types of gut bacteria which thrive in mice on a ketogenic diet and are potentially the key bacterium which communicate with neurotransmitters to halt electrical activity in the brain. This research could eventually replace diet therapy for epileptics with a pill containing the bacteria needed to communicate to neurotransmitters in the brain. The Penninsi article dives deeper into the relationship between the microbiome and depression. This article details a study that identified the absence of several species of gut bacteria in people with depression, namely Coprococcus and Dialister bacteria. These species were not missing in subjects with a high quality of life, and this persisted in participants of different ages, genders, or different antidepressant use. It is unclear whether the absence is a cause and effect, or a confound, but they were able to demonstrate that gut bacteria affected nerve cell function. Unlike the studies in the New York Times article which examined mice, the Penninsi article demonstrates this effect in humans. These findings could eventually influence treatments for depression. Oral probiotics, for example, could begin to be an accepted treatment for individuals with depression. 1. How might this area of research influence your field? 2. How does this research change the way that you think of the brain?
6 Comments
Elisabeth Nations
4/2/2019 09:55:13 pm
These articles were absolutely fascinating to me! I'd never even heard that gut bacteria could affect the brain. Discussion of probiotics and microbiomes has really only emerged in very recent years in my own experience, and I'd never heard any solid scientific research on whether bacteria-focused therapies were at all effective. Personally, I've been at once reluctant to embrace probiotics and desperately hoping they work, but really my skepticism has reigned supreme. It's very exciting to read that there is a lot of promising research on the impact of microbiomes on the brain. The Dutch study is most compelling to me, because as Kaitlyn said, although the absence of gut bacteria could just as well be a result of depression, regardless there's a link between what's happening in the brain and what's happening with the bacteria in our stomachs.
Reply
Madi Moore
4/3/2019 06:25:40 am
Nice review! I think the gut-microbiome-brain axis is so interesting. These articles hit close to home for me, as my sister has epilepsy and suffers from depression. My sister, Lilly, has had seizures for almost 16 years. It feels like she has tried almost everything in the books, including those low carb/high fats, protein and ketogenic diets, in order to reduce her seizures. Nothing has really worked thus far!
Reply
Brian Rivera
4/3/2019 06:25:51 am
This definitely challenges conceptions of the brain as an isolated object in the head. I think the notion of the nervous system is more fitting here. Rather than thinking that an illness begins in the brain, this article highlights the complex relations that exist in the body and how the beginning of these illnesses might extend the boundaries of the brain. I wonder what other seemingly brain-based/cognitive problems we care about now (e.g. ADHD, anxiety, etc.) might also extend outside the brain.
Reply
Jennifer Fortunato
4/3/2019 06:59:07 am
Thanks for the great review Kaitlyn! I agree that the gut microbiome is important, however, I do not think that it is a cure-all for diseases and disorders as it seemed to by implied by these articles. It can be useful to know what kinds of bacteria are providing signals to the brain and contributing to diseases and disorders. In answer to your questions, I think it adds another factor to be considered when doing research. My research, for example, looks at how an individuals genotype, their social environment, and the interaction between the two contributes to differences in behavior, morphology, and fitness. It may be interesting to look at the interaction between genotype and the gut microbiome and see if individuals react differently to different kinds of bacterial strains, fecal transplants, or removal of the gut microbiome entirely. I also agree with both Brian that it changes my perception of the brain being isolated from the rest of the organs to being a more integrated part with the body that can be modulated based upon other organs or microbes in the organs!
Reply
Moe Prince
4/3/2019 08:01:36 am
I thought these articles were so interesting. From reading the first one, I know I'm not alone when I say that it has never even occurred to me that bacteria in my gut could have ay effect on my behavior whatsoever. Let alone could be a key in fighting diseases like Alzheimers and Dementia. There's a lot of research to go in this field so I hesitate to say it's the end all be all, but it's certainly an interesting idea to explore.
Reply
Kaitlyn May
4/24/2019 07:55:39 pm
These articles are still my favorite topic covered in the class. I went home to Houston recently and all throughout the medical district for news releases of a recent study by Baylor College of Medicine that examined the utility of fecal transplants to treating social deficits in autism. Like mentioned in the above comments, I think that as this research develops it is going to transform multiple disciplines by imploring these disciplines to consider the brain not as an isolated system but as a dynamic system with other bodily organs.
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorThis blog is group authored by Dr. DeCaro and the students in his ANT 474/574: Neuroanthropology. Archives
April 2019
Categories |